Berrymilk Pie - Famous, award-winning Buttermilk Pie - with a topping of ripe strawberries. The expertly balanced Buttermilk Pie is a savory, creamy, custardy treat that just can’t be beat. Add a few fresh-sliced strawberries and you have Berrymilk Pie. It’s the buttermilk custard pie blend you know and love, with some sweet strawberry lovin’. It’ll melt in your mouth, y’all.